regs to riches

Share this post
šŸ›ļø Is Shopify acting like a state?
www.regs2riches.com

šŸ›ļø Is Shopify acting like a state?

TLDR; not yet, not rly.

Vass Bednar
Jan 22, 2021
8
1
Share this post
šŸ›ļø Is Shopify acting like a state?
www.regs2riches.com
Twitter avatar for @murderxbryan
Sexy BŠÆyan @murderxbryan
My presidential platform is: the post office will be super funded and you can bank there, get your hair cut there and also they will give you five $500 loans a year when you are short on cash. This money will come directly from Jeff Bezos and we will start calling him The Beeze
10:59 PM āˆ™ Oct 12, 2020
3,455Likes338Retweets
Twitter avatar for @AnandWrites
Anand Giridharadas @AnandWrites
"Be the solution to the problem you're also still causing" -- philanthrocapitalists
Twitter avatar for @Reuters
Reuters @Reuters
Mark Zuckerberg, Priscilla Chan donate $100 million more to U.S. election infrastructure https://t.co/LuSMCF4LBx https://t.co/EpLeJixmZi
3:35 PM āˆ™ Oct 13, 2020
67,804Likes10,468Retweets
Twitter avatar for @stacyfmitchell
Stacy Mitchell @stacyfmitchell
Amazon’s affordable housing pledge sounds impressive, but doesn’t actually add up to anything much at all, explains @jandrews81 in this good piece for @Curbed. If Amazon just paid taxes that would do far more good.
curbed.comAmazon’s Affordable Housing Pledge Won’t Fix AnythingThe nearly $2 trillion company will put $2 billion toward low-cost loans to developers.
1:36 PM āˆ™ Jan 13, 2021
2Likes1Retweet

Back in September (AKA when I started drafting this before abandoning it), the internet revolted at Jeff Bezos’ announcement that he was opening a tuition-free preschool for underserved children through his ā€œBezos Day One Fund.ā€Ā 

The discomfort anchored on resentment of private capital being used to fund what would otherwise be a public program provided by the government and fuelled by taxpayers. Well, that, and just general anti-billionaire/Amazon hate/resentment.Ā Ā 

Twitter avatar for @Forbes
Forbes @Forbes
Jeff Bezos announced the first Bezos Academy, a free preschool for students from low-income families on.forbes.com/6011Ga5bF by @AngelAuYeung
Image
4:28 PM āˆ™ Sep 22, 2020
4,008Likes873Retweets

The United States has a large preschool access gap and previously lacked a functioning government. That institutional weakness may have widened the window for technology CEOs to selectively invest in public policy initiatives.

*Amazon more recently announced a $2B Housing Equity Fund for Nashville, Seattle, and DC markets.

Twitter avatar for @nashvillebiz
NashvilleBizJournal @nashvillebiz
Amazon launches $2 billion Housing Equity Fund to bolster affordable housing in what Jeff Bezos calls the company's "three headquarters regions" — including Nashville.​
2:15 AM āˆ™ Jan 8, 2021
6Likes3Retweets

In the United States, it is fairly normal for big tech CEOs to invest in [vanity], policy-adjacent projects with their personal capital. ā€œNormalā€ in that it’s become normalized, not because there is consensus that these investments are desired or impactful. It’s a pretty mixed bag.Ā 

For instance, in 2010, Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg invested $100 million toward creating an education foundation in Newark, New Jersey (this failed, somewhat spectacularly).Ā  He and his spouse Priscilla oversee the Chan-Zuckerberg Initiative, which has the goal of curing, preventing, or managing all diseases ā€œin our children’s lifetime.ā€ The prototypical tech investment saviour is Bill Gates’ Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, which focuses on reducing hunger and extreme poverty in developing countries.Ā 

In June, Apple’s Tim Cook announced Apple’s $100 Million Racial Justice Initiative to promote racial equality for people of colour with a focus on ā€œeducation, economic equality, and criminal justice reform.ā€Ā 

Twitter avatar for @tim_cook
Tim Cook @tim_cook
The unfinished work of racial justice and equality call us all to account. Things must change, and Apple's committed to being a force for that change. Today, I'm proud to announce Apple’s Racial Equity and Justice Initiative, with a $100 million commitment.
Image
4:15 PM āˆ™ Jun 11, 2020
19,510Likes4,614Retweets

Similarly, Amazon committed to donating $10 million to social justice organizations; Facebook committed $10 million to groups working on racial justice; and Google promised $12M in funding to organizations addressing racial inequities.Ā 

Apple also recently allocated more than $400 million towards its $2.5 billion commitment to combat California’s housing crisis. Apple is also striving for Zero Climate Impact by 2030.

Twitter avatar for @tim_cook
Tim Cook @tim_cook
By 2030, Apple’s entire business will be carbon neutral — from supply chain to the power you use in every device we make. The planet we share can’t wait, and we want to be a ripple in the pond that creates a much larger change.
apple.comApple commits to be 100 percent carbon neutral for its supply chain and products by 2030Apple’s latest recycling invention — its Dave robot — recovers material from an iPhone component for better use in future products.
12:21 PM āˆ™ Jul 21, 2020
21,234Likes3,335Retweets

Together, the dominant technology companies are also engaged in efforts to close the digital divide and support students with virtual learning in the United States.Ā 

*These examples aren’t exhaustive but they give you a sense of some of the big-tech-fuelled interventions currently underway.

In a future-of-work context, Amazon is donating $700 million in re-skilling and up-skilling to keep its entire workforce up to speed - Upskilling 2025. This is somewhat different as it is an investment in workers that benefits the firm, but it is still a significant investment in the labour market.Ā 

šŸ‘¼ Big tech CEOs may feel compelled to create philanthropic initiatives that deflect from the more problematic and political dimensions of their business model(s) and behaviours.

Twitter avatar for @jacobinmag
Jacobin @jacobinmag
Last year, Bill Gates resigned from the board of Microsoft to focus full time on philanthropy. It’s a perfect time to remember: billionaire-funded philanthropy is a public-relations scam.
jacobinmag.comBill Gates’s Philanthropic Giving Is a RacketBill Gates recently resigned from the board of Microsoft to focus full time on philanthropy. It’s a perfect time to remember: billionaire-funded philanthropy is a public-relations scam.
1:00 AM āˆ™ Jan 21, 2021
157Likes33Retweets

Compared to a government, they are able to disburse capital much faster, and their donations are often a convenient income tax shield. It’s great for PR, sometimes good for business, and the new form of corporate social responsibility.Ā 

In her past life as a business journalist, Finance Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland’s signature observation and critique of the global super elite was their ā€œphilanthrocapitalism;ā€ used as a mechanism to shield their income from taxes and take on policy-related projects under the guise of a nonprofit or charity.

Twitter avatar for @AnandWrites
Anand Giridharadas @AnandWrites
This great hijacking by the plutocrats is what happened a century ago, it's what we broke up with the Progressive Era and the New Deal, and we can do it again if we get real about the American dream not being something that merely lives in other countries.
wgbh.orgā€˜Billionaire Supremacy Is Like White Supremacy Or Male Supremacy,’ Anand Giridharadas SaysAs the world’s billionaires get richer, American legislators are still fighting over COVID-19 relief.
10:50 PM āˆ™ Jan 4, 2021
742Likes165Retweets

The Big Tech era of selective policy activism reminds us that the firms have the capacity to behave like a state. Mark Zuckerberg has been referred to as a ā€˜king’ of Facebook’s ā€˜nation-state,’ and the ā€œfrightful fiveā€ (Amazon, Google, Apple, Microsoft and Facebook) are collectively more powerful than many governments.Ā  Policymakers are seeking to reign in this power through new digital taxation schemes and antitrust actions.Ā 

šŸ‡ØšŸ‡¦ Going back to those massive investments from Big Tech firms: we don’t really have investments comparable in scale in Canada.

This is (probably) partially because we have such strong public education and health systems, but mostly because we (luckily?) lack massive home-grown technology companies looking to solve wicked problems with their wealth. Except for one.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @Shopify
Shopify @Shopify
Today, we launched our first ever Future of Commerce report šŸŽ‰ Want to know what commerce will look like in 2021? šŸ‘€ Preview our predictions below šŸ‘‡
2:28 PM āˆ™ Dec 8, 2020
218Likes15Retweets

Our country’s largest firm, Shopify, is increasingly - and admirably -Ā  activist on a very modest scale, signalling a corporate social responsibility portfolio that is conveniently complementary to government policy priorities. Indeed, Shopify’s engagement with Indigenous and Black organizations, partnership on work-integrated learning opportunities, direct investments in training, and climate commitment make them government-like in that they are involved with a range of initiatives that are typically led by the state. To date, these engagements have been complementary to government priority areas.Ā 

🤷 What happens when their initiatives fall out of step, and/or solve for a government gap and assume the role of the state?

šŸ’ø And, is Shopify investing *enough* in these initiatives, or are they all investments in business development?Ā 

Share

Shopify has partnered with Indigenous organizations reducing barriers to entrepreneurship. To realize their mission of enabling more Indigenous-led organizations to move online in 2020, Shopify has partnered with Indigenous-led organizations in Turtle Island (Canada) and Aotearoa (New Zealand) to co-create locally and culturally relevant ecommerce education.Ā Ā Ā 

Twitter avatar for @Shopify
Shopify @Shopify
The entrepreneurial journey isn’t an easy one — especially for the Indigenous community. In light of #NationalIndigenousPeoplesDay tomorrow, we want to acknowledge the barriers facing this community.
5:35 PM āˆ™ Jun 20, 2020
95Likes31Retweets

This announcement is very much in line with Canada’s broader intentions regarding reconciliation, like the Aboriginal entrepreneurship program, which provides access to capital, and other Indigenous business development initiatives.Ā 

Shopify also invests in computing education, and has provided work-integrated learning opportunities to aspiring developers through their DevDegree.Ā Ā 

Twitter avatar for @BrandonMChu
Brandon Chu @BrandonMChu
Applications for Shopify's #DevDegree close Feb 17 - work @Shopify & earn CS degree in parallel - WE pay tuition & salary, ~$160k over 4 yrs - after grad, u have: $(vs debt) + CS degree + real world exp The best opportunity in education on the planet.
devdegree.caDev DegreeEarn a computer science degree at Shopify through a learning and placement path that’s unlike any other program. Our innovative work-integrated learning model provides hands-on experience across a breadth of disciplines and teams, giving you the confidence to jump-start your future—wherever it takes…
6:33 PM āˆ™ Jan 13, 2020
1,717Likes664Retweets

The Government of Canada’s Student Work Placement Program helps to deliver work-integrated learning opportunities, which are typically delivered at the provincial-level through partnerships between post-secondary institutions and industry.Ā Ā Ā 

Shopify’s founder and CEO Tobias Lütke chaired the Digital Industries Economic Strategy Table, which advised the federal government on how to position Canada’s digital industries for economic growth.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @NavdeepSBains
Navdeep Bains @NavdeepSBains
The new Chair of our Economic Strategy Table on digital industries will help drive Canada’s #innovation economy. Congrats @tobi! #cdnpoli #cdntech
bit.lyShopify CEO to Chair Economic Strategy Table on Digital IndustriesShopify Inc. (NYSE:SHOP)(TSX:SHOP), the leading cloud-based, multi-channel commerce platform designed for small and medium-sized businesses, today ann
4:03 PM āˆ™ Nov 8, 2017
53Likes15Retweets

Perhaps the greatest alignment between Shopify and the Government of Canada is around the environment.Ā Ā 

Shopify has committed to investing at least $5M USD annually in carbon sequestration.

Twitter avatar for @tobi
Tobi Lutke šŸŒ³šŸŒ²šŸ›’šŸ•¹ @tobi
There is too much carbon in the air and we need to use market forces to tackle this. Shopify commits to help kickstart it.
news.shopify.comWe need to talk about carbonShopify commits a minimum of $5M annually to fight for the environment with Shopify’s Sustainability Fund
1:29 PM āˆ™ Sep 12, 2019
5,032Likes591Retweets

In 2017, the Ministry of Natural Resources announced that the Government of Canada would be investing $950,000 in state-of-the-art technology that will help turn carbon emissions into useful, everyday products such as building materials, alternative fuels and consumer goods. The Government of Canada introduced a federal carbon pollution pricing system as part of its plan to implement a federal greenhouse gas emissions pricing structure.

More recently, Shopify pledged $5M annually towards protecting the environment with Shopify’s Sustainability Fund, which will invest in breakthrough sustainability technologies. The announcement came one week ahead of Canada’s Speech from the Throne.Ā Ā Ā 

The Government will launch a new fund to attract investments in making zero-emissions products and cut the corporate tax rate in half for these companies to create jobs and make Canada a world leader in clean technology. The Government will ensure Canada is the most competitive jurisdiction in the world for clean technology companies.

Twitter avatar for @BetaKit
BetaKit @BetaKit
.@Shopify looks to fight #climatechange, commits $6.6 million to new sustainability fund.
betakit.comShopify looks to fight climate change, commits $6.6 million to new sustainability fund | BetaKitShopify’s CEO Tobias Lütke has announced the company will commit at least $6.6 million CAD each year through a new initiative, the Shopify Sustainability Fund.
6:37 PM āˆ™ Sep 12, 2019
11Likes2Retweets

It has long been anticipated a green recovery lens would be emphasized in the country’s economic recovery plans, and many are betting on more money for green infrastructure.Ā While the scale of the investment is comparatively modest ($5M), it does raise the question of whether clean capitalism will necessarily be led by private firms.Ā 

*Not sure where this fits, but Shopify is the sole provider of Ontario’s legal recreational marijuana. Pretty neat that they provide the digital infrastructure for this, and worth noting how a policy decision is an opportunity for profit. Should we expect to see similar exclusivity with contracts for psychedelics? Time will tell.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @LorenPadelford
Loren Padelford @LorenPadelford
Here's whats happening across Canada with @Shopify's #Cannabis partners today: A million+ visitors, 100K+ orders, 100+ orders per min, and we're just getting started. Welcome to šŸ‡ØšŸ‡¦ #CannabisLegalization
4:17 PM āˆ™ Oct 17, 2018
292Likes122Retweets

The company’s enthusiasm for investments that complement the government’s while also building the business is striking.Ā 

In October, Shopify joined forces with Operation Hope to help create one million Black-owned businesses in the US by 2030. The intention of the partnership is to provide up to approximately $130M of resources over the course of the initiative. You can learn more about the initiative here.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @CNBC
CNBC @CNBC
Operation Hope and Shopify are teaming up to empower Black entrepreneurs, aiming to help create one million new Black-owned businesses over the next 10 years. cnb.cx/3dP8NjR
Image
10:09 PM āˆ™ Oct 25, 2020
55Likes5Retweets

So - are these social impact investments from Shopify encroaching on or assuming the role of the state?Ā 

It is notable that none of these initiatives are a ā€œshieldā€ for Shopify CEO’s Tobi Lütke’s personal capital. In 2019 Lütke and his wife Fiona McKean established the Thistledown Foundation to provide financing and grants to decarbonization technology. The Foundation has since pivoted to focus on COVID-19.

It’s also worth asking whether we anticipate or should expect MORE investment in policy-relevant areas.Ā 

šŸ“” For instance, an investment in an initiative like rural broadband would help to unlock more e-commerce.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @CANADALAND
CANADALAND @CANADALAND
The quality of your Internet is determined by two things: Where do you live? And how much money do you have? The pandemic has made long-standing disparities worse. @sula_greene reports.
canadaland.com#353 Dinosaur Internet #353 Dinosaur InternetThe pandemic has widened the digital divide, leaving people from Iqaluit to rural Alberta and Ontario fuming at ISPs like Xplornet.
12:11 PM āˆ™ Jan 4, 2021
87Likes32Retweets

While it is unlikely that Shopify will revolutionize the employment insurance system or create a national childcare program before the government does (!), their social impact engagements to date have a remarkable parallel to and alignment with federal government priorities in Canada. In fact, Shopify emerged as a ā€œpreferred partnerā€ of sorts during the push for ā€œMain street to go digital,ā€ offering free trials of their services to merchants.Ā 

Twitter avatar for @The_CDR
Canadian Design @The_CDR
Go Digital Canada is a joint initiative between Shopify and the Government of Canada that will help more small businesses engage in online commerce post-COVID borndigital.com/2020/07/16/sho…
Image
6:22 PM āˆ™ Jan 7, 2021

šŸ”ˆ Shopify has a unique policy advocacy opportunity. It could also consider becoming a stronger voice for self-employed entrepreneurs on social assistance reform: EI benefits and eligibility, family leave, and advocate for better access to financial products like mortgages.Ā 

Share

Thinking about the investments that technology companies may make in policy-relevant areas is particularly important in a pandemic context, where the role of the state is at risk of shifting as we pursue an economic recovery in the years to come.Ā Ā Ā 

If Canada’s largest tech firm is deeply engaged in reconciliation, training, carbon sequestration and investing in sustainability technologies, that feels really promising. Shopify’s continued innovation and participation in relevant policy conversations can make Canada a stronger and more resilient country. One can’t help but wonder whether they will or should do a little more to put capitalism in the hands of the many.Ā 

šŸ‘‘ Until then, the firm’s annual shareholder report is a speech from Shopify’s throne.Ā 

Leave a comment


TLDR; no.

  • Shopify is not behaving ā€œlike a governmentā€ in Canada - yet;

  • Many of the investments/initiatives they are making seem distinctly Canadian;

  • Their corporate social responsibility initiatives are novel, and tend to also build the business;Ā 

  • It is worth following how these policy areas may evolve and shift as the company continues to grow internationally;Ā 

  • It feels notable that the firm doesn’t (seem to?) fund or publish academic research *though the Thistledown Foundation does accelerate academic research projects via fastgrants.org. In 2016, Shopify had opened a ā€˜research hub’ in Montreal.


Vass BednarĀ is the Executive Director of McMaster University’s newĀ Master of Public Policy in Digital Society Program.

1
Share this post
šŸ›ļø Is Shopify acting like a state?
www.regs2riches.com
Previous
Next
1 Comment
CC
Jan 23, 2021

Society is in a bit of an uncomfortable place when governments (in both Canada and the US) willingly give up revenue via tax incentives for donations while public discourse increasingly recognizes some of the giving as distortionary and problematic. At least we acknowledge this a bit, since giving away $1000 deprives the government of less than $1000 in tax revenue and the tax benefits for charitable contributions are capped at a percentage of income (net for corporations, ~gross for individuals).

It seems like it's time to reduce the tax benefits of philanthropy (esp. corporate). Canada lets corporations deduct giving up to 75% of net income every year (the US only allows up to 25%). I'm sympathetic to the idea that Amazon or Shopify may want to offset some of the social ills they arguably cause e.g. by community investment or carbon offsets, but the larger these numbers get the more likely I would expect them to become self-serving. I don't really see why we should subsidize corporate charity in direct proportion to profit. Donate all you want, but maybe we shouldn't let you avoid tax on 75% of your profit, especially your avoidance measure may otherwise accrue value to your business?

On the personal side, I don't really understand "the super-rich selfishly engage in philanthropy to dodge taxes; they should just pay taxes intead" take. Absolutely on-board with super-rich individuals paying more tax (and the problems with depriving governments of much-needed funding). But at the same time, giving $1000 deprives you of $1000. Unless I'm missing something, you'll basically never reduce your taxes by more than $1000; it's strictly more selfish, financially speaking, to keep that money for yourself. You get social brownie points/bragging rights, but how far does that really go?

You are depriving the government of some tax revenue: ~39% tax credit on up to 75% of personal income in Canada, ~37% tax deduction up to 20-60% of personal income in the US, possible capital gains tax elimination. That's a problem and IMO there should be an absolute per-person cap on giving incentives...but it seems like success is more likely by advocating for tax reform here, rather than what I generally interpret as advocating for wealthy individuals to give less (or voluntarily forgo tax tax incentives for giving), since the former probably scales and the latter probably doesn't.

Expand full comment
ReplyCollapse
TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

Ā© 2023 Vass Bednar
Privacy āˆ™ Terms āˆ™ Collection notice
Start WritingGet the app
SubstackĀ is the home for great writing